Current:Home > MyMaui judge agrees to ask state Supreme Court about barriers to $4B wildfire settlement-LoTradeCoin
Maui judge agrees to ask state Supreme Court about barriers to $4B wildfire settlement
View Date:2024-12-24 00:07:55
HONOLULU (AP) — The Hawaii Supreme Court will be asked to weigh in on an issue that threatens to thwart a $4 billion settlement in last year’s devastating Maui wildfires.
Judge Peter Cahill on Maui agreed Friday to ask the state high court questions about how insurance companies can go about recouping money paid to policyholders.
Insurance companies that have paid out more than $2 billion in claims want to bring independent legal action against the defendants blamed for causing the deadly tragedy. It’s a common process in the insurance industry known as subrogation.
But Cahill ruled earlier this month they can seek reimbursement only from the settlement amount defendants have agreed to pay, meaning they can’t bring their own legal actions against them. The settlement was reached on Aug. 2, days before the one-year anniversary of the fires, amid fears that Hawaiian Electric, the power company that some blame for sparking the blaze, could be on the brink of bankruptcy. Other defendants include Maui County and large landowners.
Preventing insurers from going after the defendants is a key settlement term.
Lawyers representing individual plaintiffs in hundreds of lawsuits over the deaths and destruction caused by the fires filed a motion asking the judge to certify certain legal questions to the state Supreme Court.
“Given Judge Cahill’s previous orders, his ruling today is appropriate and we look forward to putting these questions into the hands of the Hawaii Supreme Court,” Jake Lowenthal, one of the attorneys representing individual plaintiffs, said after the hearing.
One of those questions is whether state statutes controlling health care insurance reimbursement also apply to casualty and property insurance companies in limiting their ability to pursue independent legal action against those who are held liable.
Lawyers representing the insurance companies have said they want to hold the defendants accountable and aren’t trying to get in the way of fire victims getting settlement money.
Individual plaintiffs’ attorneys are concerned allowing insurers to pursue reimbursement separately will subvert the deal, drain what is available to pay fire victims and lead to prolonged litigation.
It’s a “cynical tactic” to get more money out of the defendants, Jesse Creed, an attorney for individual plaintiffs, said in court of the insurance companies.
The insurance companies should be the ones who want to take the matter directly to the state Supreme Court, he said, but they haven’t joined in the motion because they know it would facilitate the settlement.
Adam Romney, an insurance attorney, disagreed, saying that they just want a resolution that works for all parties.
“While we wait to see if the Hawaii Supreme Court will take this matter up, we will continue to work towards a fair settlement through mediation for all parties concerned,” Vincent Raboteau, another attorney for the insurance companies, said in a statement after the hearing.
veryGood! (925)
Related
- What that 'Disclaimer' twist says about the misogyny in all of us
- Newspaper heiress Patty Hearst was kidnapped 50 years ago. Now she’s famous for her dogs
- Gladys Knight, Stevie Wonder, Dionne Warwick rule at pre-Grammy gala hosted by Clive Davis
- Aston Barrett, bassist for Bob Marley & The Wailers, dies at 77
- Dwayne Johnson Admits to Peeing in Bottles on Set After Behavior Controversy
- Joni Mitchell wins 10th Grammy for her 'very joyous' live album, set to perform at awards
- Inferno set off by gas blast in Kenya's capital injures hundreds, kills several; It was like an earthquake
- 'Curb your Enthusiasm' Season 12: Cast, release date, how to watch the final episodes
- Judge weighs the merits of a lawsuit alleging ‘Real Housewives’ creators abused a cast member
- The 2024 Grammy Awards are here. Taylor Swift, others poised for major wins: Live updates
Ranking
- RHOP's Candiace Dillard Bassett Gives Birth, Shares First Photos of Baby Boy
- Harry Edwards, civil rights icon and 49ers advisor, teaches life lessons amid cancer fight
- Red carpet looks from the 2024 Grammy Awards
- How Jon Bon Jovi Really Feels About Son Jake Bongiovi and Fiancé Millie Bobby Brown's Relationship
- J.Crew Outlet Quietly Drops Their Black Friday Deals - Save Up to 70% off Everything, Styles Start at $12
- Abortion access on the ballot in 2024
- Alix Earle Makes 2024 Grammys Debut After Forgetting Shoes
- Who Is Kelly Osbourne's Masked Date at the 2024 Grammys? Why This Scary Look Actually Makes Perfect Sense
Recommendation
-
Everard Burke Introduce
-
Gladys Knight, Stevie Wonder, Dionne Warwick rule at pre-Grammy gala hosted by Clive Davis
-
Many cities have anti-crime laws. The DOJ says one in Minnesota harmed people with mental illness
-
What's going on at the border? A dramatic standoff between Texas and the White House.
-
Suspected shooter and four others are found dead in three Kansas homes, police say
-
Bill Belichick thanks 'Patriots fans everywhere' in full-page ad in Boston Globe
-
Supreme Court declines to block West Point from considering race in admissions decisions for now
-
Kandi Burruss Leaving The Real Housewives of Atlanta After 14 Seasons